Featured Analysis · Counsel
Yampolskiy Hires White Collar Criminal Defense Attorney. What Does It Signal, and What Is Pro Hac Vice?
October 5 court filing identifies Michael L. Yaeger among three Carlton Fields attorneys representing SecurityScorecard and Aleksandr Yampolskiy.
Most motions in a federal lawsuit are housekeeping. A motion for admission pro hac vice, which asks a court to let out-of-state lawyers appear in a single case, is about as routine as filings get. But the one filed on October 5, 2026 in the District of Delaware tells readers something the case had not disclosed before: who SecurityScorecard and its CEO, Aleksandr Yampolskiy, have chosen to defend them. One of them, Michael L. Yaeger, is a white collar criminal defense lawyer and former federal cybercrime prosecutor.
This article's argument is that adding a white collar criminal defense lawyer to the defense of what is pleaded as a trademark, defamation and interference case is an atypical choice, and that it signals the defendants take seriously the potential criminal dimension of the case, in particular the allegations of unauthorized access to competitors' systems. That is this site's analysis, not a finding. No charges, subpoenas or government investigation of either defendant are known to this site.
01Yampolskiy and SecurityScorecard hired a white collar criminal defense lawyer
According to Carlton Fields' published biographies, the three lawyers come from different corners of practice. Mr. Yaeger's practice “focuses on government investigations, white collar defense, cybersecurity, and related compliance.” The firm says he was an AUSA in the Eastern District of New York from 2008 to 2014 and “served as his office's co-coordinator for Computer Hacking and Intellectual Property crimes.” His biography also notes matters “representing clients simultaneously in investigations by the Department of Justice or a state attorney general … and a private class action.” Ms. Yost is an intellectual-property specialist. Mr. Margulies is a commercial litigator. The firm announced its cybersecurity and white-collar expansion in a 2018 news release.
Figure 1 · Three lawyers, three practice areas
Michael L. Yaeger
Government investigations, white-collar defense, cybercrime
AUSA, E.D.N.Y. Criminal Division, 2008–2014; office co-coordinator for Computer Hacking and Intellectual Property crimes; data-breach response practice
Overlaps with
Allegations of unauthorized access and computer misuse; preservation; any parallel-proceeding questions
Eleanor M. Yost
Intellectual property
Registered patent attorney; two decades of patent, trademark, copyright and domain-name proceedings, including before the TTAB
Overlaps with
Trademark (FACTOR CYBERSECURITY) and IP ownership claims
Michael D. Margulies
Commercial litigation
Complex commercial disputes, including breach of contract and fiduciary duty, fraud and business torts
Overlaps with
Defamation, tortious interference and contract-type claims
02Why criminal defense experience matters here
The complaint is not a narrow trademark dispute. Alongside trademark and IP claims, it pleads defamation and tortious interference, and the broader record on this site includes allegations of unauthorized access to a competitor's systems, computer misuse, and retaliation. Those are allegations, unproven in any court. But a defense team facing them has practical reasons to want someone fluent in how computer-access cases are investigated.
A lawyer who has run hacking cases for the government knows what investigators look for, and what a careless civil deposition can hand them.
Discovery. Civil discovery can reach devices, logs, messages and sworn testimony. Counsel experienced with forensic evidence can negotiate the scope of device imaging and log production, and spot where civil answers could create risks elsewhere.
Privilege. Communications with counsel and work product prepared for litigation are protected, but the boundaries are contested, especially when a company and an executive share lawyers. Joint representation can work smoothly while interests align; it can become complicated if they diverge.
The Fifth Amendment. An individual may decline to answer questions that could incriminate him, even in a civil case. Corporations have no such privilege. In civil litigation, a court or jury may sometimes draw an adverse inference from silence, which makes the decision strategic and best made with advice from someone who knows both systems.
Internal investigations and preservation. Once litigation is reasonably anticipated, parties must preserve relevant evidence. Lawyers who have conducted internal investigations know how to structure them so findings are reliable and, where appropriate, privileged, and how to avoid spoliation claims.
03The firm promoted its client as litigation loomed
On August 17, 2026, Carlton Fields published an episode of its podcast No Password Required titled “Co-Founder and CEO of SecurityScorecard, on His Journey From Academics to CISO to CEO” (firm page). It is presented by John E. Clabby, a Carlton Fields lawyer who is not among the three named in the motion. The firm's summary calls SecurityScorecard “one of the world's most trusted cybersecurity brands” and covers Mr. Yampolskiy's career, company culture and board-level security. Nothing in the published summary mentions this dispute.
The timing is notable. The episode appeared after SSC's July 14 demand letter and Factor's August 10 response (Exhibit D), and 17 days before the complaint was signed. In this site's view, that timing is not a coincidence. A dispute was already in motion, and weeks later the same firm appeared as counsel of record for Mr. Yampolskiy and his company. Readers can draw their own conclusions from the sequence; the firm has not said when it was engaged.
Does it raise a legitimate concern? Precision matters here. ABA Model Rule 3.6, adopted in some form in New York, Florida and Delaware, restricts a lawyer's out-of-court statements about a matter that are likely to materially prejudice the proceeding (Rule 3.6). A career profile that never mentions the case is unlikely to fall within it, and nothing published suggests any rule was broken. Ethics rules do not bar a firm from promoting a client.
The questions worth asking are narrower:
- Reputation is contested in this case. The complaint pleads defamation, and both sides' standing in the cybersecurity market is at issue. When defense counsel's firm publicly praises a party under its own brand, readers should know the firm also represents him, and the episode page discloses no such relationship.
- Going forward, Rule 3.6 applies. Now that the firm is counsel of record, any future firm content touching the allegations, competitors or Factor would be subject to trial-publicity limits and the Court's disciplinary jurisdiction, to which the three lawyers expressly submitted.
- The firm's own interest. Model Rule 1.7(a)(2) addresses conflicts arising from a lawyer's own interests (Rule 1.7). A marketing relationship with a client is ordinarily not such a conflict, but a firm that has publicly vouched for a client's trustworthiness has a reputational stake of its own if the allegations are tested.
None of this alleges misconduct by Carlton Fields or any of its lawyers. This site has no data on how often firms profile clients who are in active disputes, and does not claim the practice is unusual.
04The counterargument, and why it falls short
The defense's likely answer is that Mr. Yaeger is simply a cybersecurity litigator. Carlton Fields' 2018 announcement describes Mr. Yaeger's practice as covering “government investigations and cybersecurity matters, as well as related regulatory issues and civil litigation,” and his biography lists data-breach response and cybersecurity compliance work. On that reading, a cybersecurity ratings company sued in a case touching on computer access might choose Mr. Yaeger for purely civil reasons.
That explanation is possible, but in this site's view it is incomplete. The claims actually pleaded in the complaint are trademark, defamation and tortious interference, which are squarely the work of the IP specialist and commercial litigator already on the team. What Mr. Yaeger adds that they do not is his background: the firm lists white collar defense first among his practice areas, and highlights his years coordinating computer hacking prosecutions in a U.S. Attorney's office. The issues where that background matters most are the ones this article describes above: Fifth Amendment decisions, privilege between a company and its CEO, and how civil testimony about alleged computer access could be used elsewhere. Those are concerns that arise when criminal exposure is at least being considered.
Retaining Mr. Yaeger does not prove that any government investigation exists, and it is not evidence that anyone committed a crime. This site knows of no charges, no subpoenas and no investigation of either defendant. The signal is about how the defendants appear to be assessing their own risk, not about what any investigator has done.
Figure 2 · The evidence-versus-inference ladder
Documented
A filed motion names three Carlton Fields lawyers as counsel for both defendants.
Documented
The firm describes Mr. Yaeger's practice as white collar defense and government investigations, and says he was a federal cybercrime prosecutor.
This site's analysis
Adding white collar criminal defense to a trademark, defamation and interference defense is atypical and signals concern about potential criminal exposure tied to the unauthorized-access allegations.
Unknown
Whether any government investigation exists. None is publicly known.
Unsupported
That any defendant committed a crime or any wrongdoing occurred.
05What the filing says
The motion, captioned in Factor Cybersecurity, Inc. and Jason Thompson v. SecurityScorecard, Inc. and Aleksandr Yampolskiy, No. 26-1119-JLH, was filed by the defendants' Delaware counsel, Philip A. Rovner and Nicole K. Pedi of Potter Anderson & Corroon LLP, under D. Del. LR 83.5. It asks that Michael D. Margulies and Michael L. Yaeger (Carlton Fields, New York) and Eleanor M. Yost (Carlton Fields, Tampa) be admitted “to represent Defendants SecurityScorecard, Inc. and Aleksandr Yampolskiy” (Motion, p. 1; read as text). The company and Mr. Yampolskiy personally share the same counsel. Each attorney signed a certification dated October 5, 2026 submitting to the Court's disciplinary jurisdiction (pp. 3–5). Page 2 carries an “Order Granting Motion” with a blank date and signature line: it is a proposed order, and this site has not seen a signed one.
Two points of precision matter. This is a civil case, and the motion is a civil filing, not a criminal one. And the filing itself says nothing about strategy; it lists names. Everything beyond that is analysis, which this article labels as such.
06Evidence versus inference
The disciplined way to read a staffing decision is to separate what a document shows from what a reader might hope it shows. The filing establishes who appears. Firm biographies establish what they have done. In this site's analysis, the choice to add white collar criminal defense experience signals that the defendants are planning for the computer-access allegations to carry potential criminal implications. What the record does not show is that any investigation exists or that any wrongdoing occurred.
07What would be a stronger signal
If a parallel government inquiry ever exists, it would likely surface through events more telling than a lawyer's résumé:
Grand jury or agency subpoenas
Disclosed in filings, reported, or acknowledged
Agency contact
A target or subject letter, or confirmed interviews by investigators
Notices of appearance by additional criminal counsel
Especially separate counsel for the individual defendant
Fifth Amendment assertions
Refusals to answer at deposition or in written discovery
Motions to stay civil discovery
Requests citing a parallel criminal matter
Privilege disputes over an internal investigation
Fights over whether forensic or investigative reports are protected
None of these has occurred on the public record. This site will report them if they do, and will note just as clearly if the case proceeds as an ordinary commercial dispute.
08Chronology and sources
Aug 17, 2026
Carlton Fields publishes a podcast episode profiling Mr. Yampolskiy.
Sept 3, 2026
Federal complaint signed (D. Del. No. 1:26-cv-01119).
Oct 5, 2026
Delaware counsel moves to admit Margulies, Yaeger and Yost as counsel for both defendants.
Pending
Court action on the motion. The order attached to the motion is a proposed order; this site has not seen a signed order.
Docket
Sources
- Motion and Proposed Order for Admission Pro Hac Vice, Factor Cybersecurity, Inc. v. SecurityScorecard, Inc., C.A. No. 26-1119-JLH (D. Del. Oct. 5, 2026), at 1–5 (full text · download PDF).
- Carlton Fields, “No Password Required: Co-Founder and CEO of SecurityScorecard” (Aug. 17, 2026)
- ABA Model Rules of Professional Conduct: Rule 3.6 · Rule 1.7
- Carlton Fields biographies: Michael L. Yaeger · Eleanor M. Yost · Michael D. Margulies
- Carlton Fields news release (2018)
- Complaint (text) · Case timeline · All documents
09What is pro hac vice?
Pro hac vice is Latin for “for this occasion.” A lawyer is licensed by a particular state, and federal district courts generally admit only members of their own bar. When a party wants a lawyer from elsewhere to work on a single case, local counsel asks the court to admit that lawyer for that case alone. Admission does not make the lawyer a member of the court's bar for any other matter.
In the District of Delaware, Local Rule 83.5 governs the process. An attorney who is not a member of the Delaware bar may be admitted on motion by a Delaware-admitted attorney, who must remain associated with the case. Each applicant certifies that they are in good standing in the jurisdictions where they are admitted and submits to the Court's disciplinary jurisdiction for any misconduct in the case. Delaware counsel generally must sign filings and be ready to appear.
That is what the October 5 filing does. Delaware counsel moved to admit Michael D. Margulies, Michael L. Yaeger and Eleanor M. Yost of Carlton Fields to represent both SecurityScorecard and Mr. Yampolskiy. The filing includes a proposed order; a proposed order is a draft the judge may sign, not a ruling. This site has not seen a signed order granting the motion and will note it when one appears on the docket.
Pro hac vice motions are routine and are usually granted. The filing itself says nothing about the merits of the case. Its value to readers is that it names, on the public record, who the defendants chose to defend them.
At a glance
- Admits an out-of-state lawyer for one case only.
- Requires a sponsoring local (Delaware) attorney who stays on the case.
- The admitted lawyer submits to the court's discipline and rules.
- A proposed order is not a granted order.
- Read the full text of the motion.
Disclosure and right of response. This site is owned by Jason Thompson, a plaintiff in this case. Nothing here alleges guilt. SecurityScorecard, Mr. Yampolskiy and their counsel are invited to respond; substantive responses will be published or fairly summarized.
Related investigations
Investigations · Federal investigation
FBI Launches Formal Probe into SecurityScorecard CEO Aleksandr Yampolskiy
The FBI’s Boston Cyber Task Force interviewed multiple witnesses about Yampolskiy’s alleged access to Bitsight and requested evidence tracing Bitsight material into SecurityScorecard’s product.
Opinion
DOJ Flameout and Yampolskiy’s Criminal Defense Attorney Michael Yaeger Acts Unethically, Then Complains About the Consequences
A day after his firm sent preservation letters to a Factor executive and an advisor, Yampolskiy’s defense attorney Michael Yaeger demanded that the Chronicle come down. His email identified no factual error in the articles he attached.
Opinion
Crooked Michael Margulies Used Preservation Letters to Intimidate Witnesses
On November 19, Carlton Fields attorney Michael D. Margulies emailed a Factor Cybersecurity executive and an advisor at their personal addresses. They were already represented by counsel.
Analysis · Executive accountability
From NS8 to SecurityScorecard: When Cybersecurity Executives Become the Risk
The NS8 scandal exposed fraud and whistleblower retaliation inside a company selling fraud prevention. Allegations in Factor Cybersecurity's federal lawsuit raise a different question: Who holds cybersecurity executives accountable when their own conduct is challenged?
Investigations · Legal Analysis
AleksandrYampolskiy.com: A Masterclass in Leveling the Playing Field Through Asymmetric Advantage
SecurityScorecard's CEO publicly criticized a former executive and his startup. A landmark federal appellate decision involving Jerry Falwell explains why an independent criticism website bearing his name is not unlawful merely for using it, and how modern tools let founders level the playing field.
Analysis · Computer Fraud and Abuse Act
Did Yampolskiy's Alleged Competitor Hacking Cross the Line Drawn by the Supreme Court in Van Buren?
How the Supreme Court’s landmark CFAA decision applies to alleged unauthorized competitor access described in Factor Cybersecurity v. SecurityScorecard, and why valid credentials do not necessarily establish lawful authorization.
Investigations · Litigation
Something to Hide? Yampolskiy's SecurityScorecard Settled Competitor Lawsuit Just 10 Days After Judge Ordered Competitive Intelligence Discovery
SecurityScorecard sued a competitor over alleged improper competitive intelligence gathering. But when a federal judge ordered scrutiny of SecurityScorecard's own practices, the case settled just ten days later. Coincidence, or did the discovery order change everything?
Investigation · Litigation tactics
Drug Use, Threats, and Anonymous Emails: Who Are theothermarkh@proton.me and markh1980ny@gmail.com, and Why Do They Matter to SecurityScorecard & Yampolskiy's Defense?
Two unidentified email accounts. Allegations of antisemitic statements, threats, and drug use in federal litigation involving a longtime SecurityScorecard executive. And the same outside attorney raising questions about anonymous communications in another lawsuit. Is there a recurring litigation strategy, or something more troubling happening inside SecurityScorecard?
Analysis · Litigation exposure
From Unicorn to Firesale: Why Impacted Companies Hold SecurityScorecard’s Death Warrant
If allegations of unauthorized access to competitor platforms were ever corroborated, the leverage would sit with the companies allegedly accessed. A conditional, claim-by-claim look at the civil, criminal, commercial and valuation stakes, with an interactive model.
Litigation · Evidence · Corporate Conduct
Bad Faith: Factor Offered a Code Review to Yampolskiy's Attorneys. It Was Never About IP. This Was About Bullying.
SecurityScorecard was offered multiple opportunities to resolve its concerns, including third-party forensic examination and access to Factor's application codebase. Why did a dispute that could have been investigated privately become a federal lawsuit and a public confrontation?
Analysis · Commentary on the court record
Watching for the Response: In the Heid Lawsuit, SecurityScorecard’s Hired Guns Went Scorched Earth
A former executive alleged his name and altered likeness were used to sell AI products, and that his equity was threatened when he objected. SecurityScorecard answered with two contract counterclaims and a set of personal allegations. One case, read closely, through both filings.
Board Spotlight · Governance
Richard Seewald Promised Billions. The Record Shows a Revolving Door, a 70% Markdown and a Fight SecurityScorecard Didn’t Need
An investor’s thirteen-year bet, a billion-dollar projection, a secondary-market markdown, and the governance test confronting Evolution Equity Partners.
Investigation · Evidence
The Smoking Gun: What Evidence Would Determine If Yampolskiy Hacked Competitors, and Does Factor Have It?
A Slack message, a Dropbox link, an access log, an invoice. What the federal record already holds on alleged competitor access, what discovery would have to establish, and why each link in the chain must stand on its own.
Analysis · Corporate governance
SecurityScorecard’s Board Was Warned. Could Shareholders Sue Under Caremark?
How Delaware’s Caremark doctrine could expose longtime directors to liability if they ignored warnings of alleged executive misconduct.
Featured Analysis · Discovery
Following the Evidence: Emma Mason Furniture, Alleged Cyber Espionage, and Federal Discovery
How a federal trial could confirm or disprove the alleged Emma Mason Furniture hacking scheme and Aleksandr Yampolskiy's involvement.
Analysis · Delaware law
Delaware Stalking and Harassment Laws: Did Repeated Communications Targeting Jason Thompson Cross the Legal Threshold?
What 11 Del. C. §§ 1311 and 1312 actually require, which communications are documented, which are only alleged, and what investigators would need to establish.