BreakingFBI Launches Formal Probe into SecurityScorecard CEO Aleksandr Yampolskiy
AI voice reads the article text aloud.

Opinion

Crooked Michael Margulies Used Preservation Letters to Intimidate Witnesses

On November 19, Carlton Fields attorney Michael D. Margulies emailed a Factor Cybersecurity executive and an advisor at their personal addresses. They were already represented by counsel.

5 min readOpinion

On November 19, Carlton Fields attorney Michael D. Margulies emailed a Factor Cybersecurity executive and an advisor at their personal addresses. They were already represented by counsel. Both letters opened with SecurityScorecard’s allegations against Factor and its founder, including “unauthorized use of SSC’s intellectual property, bad faith, and breach of fiduciary duty.” Factor calls those accusations false and defamatory and says Margulies used a document preservation request to put them directly before people whose trust the company depends on.

Factor’s advisors and employees are represented by counsel. This is a clear violation of the rules and Crooked Michael Margulies knows it.

Margulies copied Factor’s lawyer, who had entered an appearance for the company and its founder two days earlier. He asked both recipients to preserve records dating back to January 1, 2017, acknowledge receipt by December 4, and contact his firm about any difficulty, “through your counsel if appropriate.” The advisor had joined Factor the previous week, according to the company. The letters requested preservation only. Both recipients forwarded them to Factor’s founder.

Four months before Margulies sent the letters, a Factor advisor relayed a message attributed to Yampolskiy on or about July 12, 2026. In the preserved text exchange, the advisor quoted the warning: “I plan to subpoena all the advisors soon” and “So you probably don’t want to be on it.” The advisor added, “That was the msg I got.” Factor cites that warning as evidence that pressure on its advisors began before it filed the Delaware lawsuit.

Factor identifies the recipients as potential witnesses in its Delaware federal lawsuit and says its counsel represents them in this matter. The company accuses Margulies of witness intimidation and professional misconduct, describing him as an “unethical hired gun.” Factor plans to submit the letters and emails to New York’s First Department Attorney Grievance Committee and ask federal authorities to examine whether Margulies intended to influence witnesses.

SecurityScorecard asked a federal judge to put the Delaware lawsuit on hold for arbitration. Its own brief acknowledges that “Thompson did not sign the 2023 PIIA.” That is the employee agreement containing the arbitration clause. The signed offer letter said he “will be required” to sign the separate form. SecurityScorecard also acknowledges that Factor never signed any of the agreements it invokes. Its case for arbitration rests on a signed 2017 agreement from an earlier period of employment and its argument that accepting benefits in 2023 bound the parties. Factor maintains that later contracts superseded the 2017 agreement and that no arbitration agreement governs this dispute.

Factor calls the tactic corrupt. It accuses SecurityScorecard’s attorneys, including Margulies, of manufacturing consent to arbitration by treating an unsigned form as a binding promise. Thompson signed the 2023 offer letter, but SecurityScorecard acknowledges he never signed the separate employee agreement containing the arbitration clause. Factor says the attorneys are trying to bury the civil case and keep allegations of criminal conduct by Yampolskiy out of public view, including the allegation reported to federal authorities that he accessed a competitor’s systems without authorization.

On October 16, defense counsel proposed that both sides remove public posts about the dispute. Margulies was copied. Factor says it took its material down and regards the subsequent circulation of accusations to private inboxes as a breach of that ceasefire. The company intends to seek leave to add Margulies as a defendant and cite the two contacts in support of its tortious interference claims.

Factor and its founder say they will enter into no settlement or other agreement with SecurityScorecard or Yampolskiy. They intend to pursue a civil jury trial and provide evidence and testimony to help the Department of Justice secure convictions of Yampolskiy and any co-conspirators the evidence identifies.

The two-page letter follows. Personal identifiers have been redacted.

Redacted preservation letter

Two pages · PDF · Personal identifiers redacted

Page 1 of the redacted preservation letterPage 2 of the redacted preservation letter
[Letterhead and contact details redacted] November 19, 2026 [Redacted] Re: SecurityScorecard, Inc. v. [Redacted] and Factor Cybersecurity, Inc. Dear [Redacted]: We are counsel for SecurityScorecard, Inc. (“SSC”) in the above-referenced proceeding against [Redacted] and Factor Cybersecurity, Inc. (together, “Factor”). This dispute concerns alleged breaches of [Redacted]’s agreements and contractual and policy obligations to SSC, as well as disparagement of SSC, competitive harm to SSC, unauthorized use of SSC’s intellectual property, bad faith, and breach of fiduciary duty. We understand that you are a [Redacted] to Factor. You may therefore possess records relevant to this dispute. Please promptly take reasonable steps to preserve all documents, data, and electronically stored information. You are expected to promptly take reasonable steps to preserve such documents, data, and information within your possession, custody, or control, for the period January 1, 2017 to the present, and preserve any subsequently created or received records. Please do not destroy, delete, or materially alter such records and take reasonable steps to prevent their loss through routine deletion or other processes. Please also preserve relevant paper records and electronic information, including email, text messages, messaging application communications, shared drive and cloud workspace records, and records on devices or accounts used for the relevant engagement. And please preserve native files and associated metadata, materially different versions, annotated copies, and unique attachments. Please avoid preservation methods that strip metadata or replace native records with printouts or screenshots alone. Also, to the extent applicable, please notify any of your personnel reasonably likely to hold relevant records and coordinate with appropriate IT personnel or service providers to suspend routine deletion, auto-delete, ephemeral-message settings, or other processes to the extent reasonably necessary to prevent loss of relevant information. If potentially relevant information exists only in a backup or other source that presents a material preservation burden, please contact us promptly to discuss an appropriate approach before it is lost. Relevant materials may be sought through appropriate formal process. This letter requests preservation only; it does not request production of documents or disclosure of privileged or [Page 2] protected information, or ask you to waive any privilege, protection, confidentiality obligation, or objection. Please preserve potentially relevant materials even if you believe they may be privileged or otherwise protected. Please acknowledge receipt by December 4, 2026 and identify the appropriate contact for preservation-related communications. If you anticipate material difficulty or burden in preserving any identified source, please contact us promptly, through your counsel if appropriate, so that we can discuss a reasonable approach. We are available to further discuss if you have any questions. [Signature redacted] cc: [Redacted] (by email)