BreakingFBI Launches Formal Probe into SecurityScorecard CEO Aleksandr Yampolskiy
AI voice reads the article text aloud.
Ownership disclosure: this site is owned by Jason Thompson, a plaintiff in Factor Cybersecurity, Inc. v. SecurityScorecard, Inc. (D. Del., No. 1:2026cv01119). It is not an official source. This article is analysis and commentary; allegations by either side in the Heid case were never adjudicated. Not legal advice.

Analysis · Commentary on the court record

Watching for the Response: In the Heid Lawsuit, SecurityScorecard’s Hired Guns Went Scorched Earth

A former executive alleged his name and altered likeness were used to sell AI products, and that his equity was threatened when he objected. SecurityScorecard answered with two contract counterclaims and a set of personal allegations. One case, read closely, through both filings.

9 min readAnalysis · Not legal advice

01The constant

Read SecurityScorecard’s leadership history from left to right and one line never breaks. Since 2013, chief product officers have come and gone: Simon Hunt, then Ram Krishnan, then Adam Bixler. The revenue chair passed from Bill Hogan to Hein Hellemons and, eventually, to Peter Jantzen. Finance went from Robert Gibney to Eric Larsson; technology from Christos Kalantzis to Avesta Hojjati to Rand Davis; marketing from Cindy Zhou to Claire Trimble. In September 2026 the company named Sarah Walker president. Through all of it, Aleksandr Yampolskiy has been chief executive.

Turnover is not misconduct, and the public record does not say why most of these executives left. But when a company cycles through senior leaders, the way it treats the ones who leave becomes a question in its own right. Most departures end quietly. One that did not, and that left a public paper trail, is the 2025 lawsuit brought by Alexander Heid, SecurityScorecard’s former Chief Research & Development Officer. Read through both sides’ filings, it shows how SecurityScorecard and its outside counsel responded when a former insider took the company to court. The headline’s “scorched earth” is this site’s characterization of that one response, not a finding about a pattern.

02The common denominator

Count the names. Between 2013 and 2026, the public record places 35 people, across 38 leadership stints, in SecurityScorecard’s top product, revenue, finance, technology, marketing, legal, people and president roles, not counting the CEO. Some lanes have turned over three and four times; several seats changed hands within a year. That is dozens of senior executives through a revolving door, at a company that has had exactly one chief executive.

Figure 1 · Executive departures and successions around one CEO, 2013–2026

Showing latest years
201320142015201620172018201920202021202220232024202520262027

CEO

Product

Revenue

Finance

Technology

Marketing

Legal

People

President

Tap or hover a name for its dates and sources. At least 15 role changes across product, revenue, finance, technology, marketing, legal and people; one CEO since 2013.

Method. Each line is one person's tenure in a role as shown in public sources, chiefly LinkedIn profiles, company releases and press reports. Actual dates may differ from those sources. Solid ends are dated by a company release or the person's own announcement; dashed lines mark approximate or third-party dates. An open end means no departure date is public. Overlaps (for example in revenue leadership) may reflect different titles. This is not a turnover rate, and it does not say why anyone left. Select a name for its sources.

Leadership changes alone do not show why anyone left, and this chart does not attribute any departure to the CEO or to a dispute. Dates and sources for each name appear when you select it.

When the conflict becomes public, the same name keeps surfacing. In the Heid case, Aleksandr Yampolskiy was not a bystander to a corporate dispute: he was sued personally, and the only threat quoted in the complaint, “I can always claw back your shares,” is attributed to him (Complaint ¶ 66). He is likewise sued personally in Factor Cybersecurity, Inc. and Jason Thompson v. SecurityScorecard, Inc. and Aleksandr Yampolskiy, a case brought in part by this site’s owner, which alleges that he “personally directed, authorized, made, and ratified” the conduct at issue (Factor Complaint ¶ 7). Those allegations are also unadjudicated. Different disputes, different plaintiffs, one recurring figure at the top.

That pattern is this site’s observation, not a finding. Executives leave for promotions, buyouts, board decisions and personal reasons, and no public record ties most of these exits to Yampolskiy or to any dispute with him. The allegations against him in the Heid case were denied and never decided. But a board weighing governance does not need a verdict to notice where the turnover, the litigation and the drama converge. In SecurityScorecard’s case, the record points to the corner office.

03What Heid alleged

Heid filed suit on February 28, 2025, in the Southern District of New York, against SecurityScorecard and Yampolskiy (Complaint, ECF 1). His central allegation was that the company built a marketing campaign around him without permission. According to the complaint, SecurityScorecard promoted an artificial-intelligence product called “HEID AI” with an advertisement on its website that bore his surname and his photograph from the company’s own leadership page, “altered to appear as though Heid is of non-human, i.e., robotic, origin” (Complaint ¶¶ 25–28). He alleged the company also animated his image at the 2024 RSA Conference and used his likeness in connection with Black Hat USA 2024. The complaint frames the campaign itself as retaliation for what the defendants “perceived as Heid’s difficult behavior following his termination” (¶ 2).

He pleaded four counts: unauthorized commercial use of his name or likeness under Florida statute; violation of New York Civil Rights Law §§ 50 and 51, which bar using a living person’s name or picture for advertising without written consent; invasion of privacy under Florida common law; and breach of his stock-option grant agreement.

The equity count is where the complaint turns sharp. His 2015 grant agreement gave him 90 days after leaving to exercise his options. He alleged that on May 13, 2024, General Counsel Owen Denby wrote that “the 1 year extension should be updated and reflected in Shareworks later this week,” moving his deadline to April 1, 2025 (Complaint ¶¶ 62–63). On June 6, 2024, Heid’s attorney sent a demand letter telling SecurityScorecard to stop using his likeness. In the days that followed, Heid alleged, Yampolskiy texted him “I can always claw back your shares” and “[w]ould you prefer us to do it[?]”; the company then terminated the extension and imposed a July 31, 2024 deadline (¶¶ 65–70). If true, the sequence describes an objection to the campaign followed by a threat to his equity and then the loss of a benefit he had been promised. SecurityScorecard denied these allegations, and none was proven.

Figure 2 · The Heid dispute, by filing

  1. July 18, 2014

    Heid signs the Proprietary Information and Inventions and Non-Competition Agreement (Answer, Counterclaims ¶ 24).

    Answer
  2. May 14, 2015

    Stock Option Grant Agreement; unexercised options lapse 90 days after service ends, absent death or termination for cause (Complaint ¶¶ 55–57).

    Complaint
  3. Aug. 9–10 & Sept. 1, 2023

    SecurityScorecard says employees told Heid “HEID” would be used in a campaign, and that he replied “Hahaha t[h]is is awesome” and “This is awesome” (Counterclaims ¶¶ 12–14).

    Answer
  4. Feb. 9 & 13, 2024

    After the “H.E.I.D.” campaign began, SecurityScorecard says Heid acknowledged it twice more (Counterclaims ¶¶ 15–16).

    Answer
  5. Mar.–Apr. 1, 2024

    Employment ends. The complaint says SecurityScorecard terminated him in or about March 2024; the Answer admits he left on April 1, 2024 (Complaint ¶ 24; Answer ¶ 24).

    Complaint
  6. Apr. 8, 2024

    Separation Agreement executed, with a “Release of All Claims” in Section 11 (Counterclaims ¶¶ 17–18).

    Answer
  7. Early May 2024

    Heid says he learned of a HEID AI ad on the company website using his name and his leadership-page photo altered to look robotic (Complaint ¶¶ 25–30).

    Complaint
  8. May 13, 2024

    General Counsel Owen Denby emails that the one-year extension “should be updated and reflected in Shareworks later this week” (Complaint ¶ 62).

    Complaint
  9. June 6, 2024

    Heid’s attorney sends a demand letter: cease and desist, and account for use of his likeness (Complaint ¶ 65).

    Complaint
  10. Days after June 6, 2024

    Heid alleges texts from Yampolskiy: “I can always claw back your shares” and “[w]ould you prefer us to do it[?]”; the extension is terminated and a July 31, 2024 deadline imposed (Complaint ¶¶ 66–70).

    Complaint
  11. Feb. 28, 2025

    Heid files a four-count complaint in the Southern District of New York.

    Complaint
  12. Apr. 16, 2025

    SecurityScorecard, Inc. and Yampolskiy answer through Crowell & Moring LLP; SecurityScorecard, Inc. alone asserts two counterclaims.

    Answer
  13. Apr. 22–23, 2025

    Heid’s counsel emails that the counterclaims contain “immaterial, impertinent or scandalous” matter subject to Rule 12(f); defendants say they will amend (ECF 19, pp. 12–13).

    ECF 19
  14. May 16, 2025

    First Amended Answer with Counterclaims (ECF 15) asserts four counterclaims and keeps the personal background paragraphs (as described in ECF 19, pp. 13, 15).

    ECF 19
  15. June 11, 2025

    Heid moves to strike Counterclaims ¶¶ 6–11 as “patently gratuitous” and to dismiss most counterclaims (ECF 19).

    ECF 19
  16. July 23, 2025

    Dismissal with prejudice following a reported settlement. No merits ruling; terms not disclosed.

    Order
Each entry is labeled by the document it comes from. Complaint entries are Heid’s allegations; Answer entries are SecurityScorecard’s. Neither was tested by a court.

04“I Can Always Claw Back Your Shares”: The Financial Pressure Alleged by Heid

Heid’s lawyers laid out the equity dispute again on June 11, 2025, in a memorandum supporting his motion to strike or dismiss the company’s counterclaims (ECF 19, pp. 8–11). According to that filing, Heid held options under a Stock Option Grant Agreement dated May 14, 2015, governed by SecurityScorecard’s 2013 Equity Incentive Plan. The agreement said the options would “terminate and be canceled to the extent not exercised within ninety (90) days” after he stopped working for the company, with exceptions for death or termination for cause, and Heid said neither applied (ECF 19, p. 8).

Heid alleged that SecurityScorecard agreed to give him twelve months instead, until April 1, 2025, and that on May 13, 2024, General Counsel Owen Denby confirmed that “the 1 year extension should be updated and reflected in Shareworks later this week” (ECF 19, p. 9). Then came the dispute over the “HEID AI” campaign. After his lawyer’s June 6, 2024 cease-and-desist letter, the filing says, Yampolskiy “sent multiple threatening texts” stating “I can always claw back your shares” and “[w]ould you prefer us to do it[?]” (ECF 19, p. 10). Heid alleged that SecurityScorecard then withdrew the extension and imposed a July 31, 2024 exercise deadline, “thereby causing him to incur economic losses” (ECF 19, p. 11).

Two things need to be kept apart. The “claw back” line is an alleged threat; this site has seen no allegation that SecurityScorecard actually confiscated shares Heid already owned. The concrete dispute was over the deadline to exercise his options. That matters more than it may sound. A stock option is a right to buy shares at a fixed price, and exercising it costs money, often a large amount, and can trigger taxes in the year of exercise, even when the shares cannot easily be sold. Moving a deadline from April 2025 to July 2024 means an employee must either find that money roughly eight months early or let the unexercised options expire and lose them. Heid said he was “forced prematurely to exercise his Option.” SecurityScorecard denied these allegations, and no court decided them.

05What SecurityScorecard answered

The company’s Answer, filed April 16, 2025, was filed for both defendants by Crowell & Moring LLP. It denied Heid’s allegations, raised eight affirmative defenses, and went further (Answer and Counterclaims, ECF 14). It said Heid departed on April 1, 2024 (Answer ¶ 24), signed a Separation Agreement on April 8 that included a release (§ 11), and had known about the campaign for months. It quoted his internal replies, “Hahaha t[h]is is awesome” on August 10, 2023 and “This is awesome” on September 1, 2023, and said he acknowledged the “H.E.I.D.” campaign again on February 9 and 13, 2024 (Counterclaims ¶¶ 12–16). The company styled its counterclaim as compulsory under Federal Rule 13(a), meaning it arose from the same events and had to be raised now or lost.

On that footing, SecurityScorecard, Inc. asserted two counterclaims. Yampolskiy, although a named defendant, asserted none personally. The first alleged that by suing over a campaign he already knew about, Heid breached his release. The second invoked an invention-assignment agreement he signed on July 18, 2014: if Heid had been aware of the campaign, given feedback and approved it, the company argued, any related intellectual property was assigned to SecurityScorecard, and suing over it breached that agreement. For both, the company sought declarations of breach, damages, and its costs and attorneys’ fees.

Figure 3 · Two counterclaims, side by side

Counterclaim I

Breach of the release

Contract
Separation Agreement, Apr. 8, 2024 (§ 11)
Theory
Heid knew of the campaign before he signed, so his claims about it were released, and suing over them was itself a breach.
Trigger
Filing the lawsuit

Counterclaim II

Breach of the invention-assignment agreement

Contract
Proprietary information, inventions and noncompetition assignment agreement, July 18, 2014
Theory
Heid’s alleged awareness of, feedback on and approval of the campaign meant related intellectual property belonged to SecurityScorecard, and suing over it breached the agreement.
Trigger
Filing the lawsuit
Neither count depends on the personal background allegations in paragraphs 6–11 of the Answer.
Asserted by SecurityScorecard, Inc. only; Aleksandr Yampolskiy did not assert counterclaims personally. Both sought declarations of breach, damages, costs and attorneys’ fees. Neither was adjudicated.

The logic of the counterclaims is worth stating plainly. The act alleged to be the breach was the lawsuit itself. A former executive who sued to stop the use of his own name was told, in effect, that suing was the violation, and that he might owe the company’s legal bills for doing it. These are recognizable legal theories, and releases exist to end disputes. A court might also have concluded that a person’s name and face are not “intellectual property” an employee can assign by approving a marketing idea. No court reached the question.

06The allegations the claims did not need

Before the counterclaims, the Answer includes a background section, paragraphs 6 through 11, about Heid himself. Each paragraph is pleaded “upon information and belief.” They allege that he controlled social media accounts under a pseudonym, that followers of those accounts posted offensive commentary, and that this drew complaints to the company on or about February 26, 2024. They repeat a third party’s secondhand statements about his conduct toward that person, and allege that he left aggressive voicemails for company leaders, including in the early hours of July 4, 2024 (Answer ¶¶ 6–11). The pleading also repeats the third party’s characterizations of his health; this site does not reproduce them.

None of this was tested. There are no court findings, Heid never had a trial at which to answer it, and the third party’s claims appear in the pleading secondhand. This site treats none of it as true and draws no conclusion about Heid’s character, conduct or health.

The question is why it was there. Neither counterclaim depends on it. Whether Heid released his claims turns on the Separation Agreement and what he knew when he signed. Whether he assigned rights turns on a 2014 contract and his role in a campaign. Pseudonymous accounts, a third party’s complaints and voicemails left months after he signed bear on neither. Lawyers include background for many reasons, and the company may have had ones the filing does not state. But the gap between what the claims required and what the pleading said is visible on the face of the document, and in a public filing that gap is not cost-free for the person described.

07Rule 11 and irrelevant allegations

Federal courts have tools for exactly this question. Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 11(b), an attorney who signs a pleading certifies, after a reasonable inquiry, that it is not being presented “for any improper purpose, such as to harass, cause unnecessary delay, or needlessly increase the cost of litigation,” and that its factual contentions have, or are likely to have, evidentiary support. Pleading “upon information and belief,” as Answer paragraphs 6 through 11 do, is allowed, but it does not excuse the inquiry. A lawyer may plead what is believed; a lawyer may not plead what was never checked.

A separate rule speaks even more directly to material that serves no purpose in a case. Rule 12(f) lets a court strike from any pleading “any redundant, immaterial, impertinent, or scandalous matter,” on its own or on a party’s motion. Federal courts have described “scandalous” matter as any allegation that “unnecessarily reflects on the moral character of an individual.” Striking is disfavored, and courts often say it should be granted only when the challenged material “has no possible relation to the controversy.” Allegations about pseudonymous accounts, a third party’s complaints and late-night voicemails, attached to counterclaims about a release and an assignment agreement, are the kind of matter such motions are written about.

The consequences are real but rarely reached. A party seeking Rule 11 sanctions must first serve the motion and give the other side 21 days to withdraw or correct the filing, a “safe harbor” built to encourage retraction over punishment (Rule 11(c)(2)). Sanctions, if imposed, must be limited to what deters repetition: nonmonetary directives, a penalty paid into court, or some of the movant’s fees. Separately, under 28 U.S.C. § 1927, an attorney who “multiplies the proceedings in any case unreasonably and vexatiously” may be required “to satisfy personally the excess costs, expenses, and attorneys’ fees reasonably incurred because of such conduct,” and courts retain inherent power to sanction bad-faith litigation conduct.

There is also a defamation dimension. Statements made in court filings are generally protected by the litigation privilege, which in New York is absolute for anything that “may possibly be pertinent” to the case. The test is deliberately generous: New York’s highest court has held that statements in judicial proceedings lose protection only if “so obviously impertinent as not to admit of discussion, and so needlessly defamatory as to warrant the inference of express malice” (Martirano v. Frost, 1969, quoting Youmans v. Smith, 1897). That is a high bar, rarely cleared, and it is the only place the shield is open to challenge. The privilege also explains why a filing can be an effective place to put damaging claims about someone. The person described generally cannot sue over them, and they remain on the public docket after the case ends.

None of this establishes that anything improper happened here. No court ruled on the relevance of those paragraphs, and no Rule 11 motion appears in the filings this site has reviewed. SecurityScorecard and its counsel may have regarded the background as bearing on Heid’s credibility, his damages or the equities of the dispute. The point is narrower: the federal rules require a purpose for what goes into a pleading. As the next section shows, Heid’s lawyers argued in court that these paragraphs had none.

08When Court Filings Become a Vehicle for Reputational Damage

Heid’s lawyers did not let the background section pass. On April 22, 2025, six days after the original Answer, they emailed SecurityScorecard’s counsel warning that the counterclaims contained allegations that were “immaterial, impertinent or scandalous” and could be stricken under Rule 12(f). The next day, according to ECF 19, the defendants said they would amend. They filed a First Amended Answer with Counterclaims on May 16, 2025 (ECF 15), which expanded the company’s claims to four: three for breach of the Separation Agreement (its release, non-disparagement and “no actions or claims” sections) and one for breach of the invention-assignment agreement (ECF 19, pp. 12–13).

The personal background stayed. On June 11, 2025, Heid moved to strike paragraphs 6 through 11 of the amended counterclaims and to dismiss most of the counterclaims (ECF 19). The memorandum describes what those paragraphs contained: Heid’s purported use of the pseudonym “Jake Newman” on social media to convey “highly offensive and derogatory” material; claims that “over the years” the company and unidentified third parties thought him “erratic and unstable,” that he “medicates himself with heavy drugs,” and that people sought “police and legal protection” from him (ECF 19, p. 15). Heid’s lawyers called the allegations “patently gratuitous” and argued they “appear to suggest a rationale for SSC’s termination of Plaintiff’s employment when there are no claims advanced in the Complaint contesting his termination,” and were “plainly alleged for the improper purpose of maligning, and, therefore, prejudicing Plaintiff” (pp. 15–16). More broadly, they argued that the pleading was “an obvious effort to ‘double down’ on Plaintiff to drive up his costs of litigation unnecessarily” (p. 14).

The motion also points to the company’s own records. In a footnote, Heid’s lawyers wrote that SecurityScorecard’s document production showed that, after an internal investigation, its Director of Human Resources Business Partner, Courtney LaTurner, told Chief People Officer Jeff Alvarez in February 2024 that Heid’s actions as “Jake Newman” were not “inflammatory” or “illegal,” nor “insulting or threatening” (ECF 19, p. 15 n.1, citing an exhibit to the MacMull declaration). This site has not seen that exhibit, and the description is Heid’s lawyers’ account of it. If accurate, it means the company pleaded, “upon information and belief,” allegations about the “Jake Newman” accounts that its own HR review had found were not threatening.

The legal standard Heid invoked is demanding. To strike material under Rule 12(f), the memorandum notes, a party must show that no admissible evidence would support it, that it has no bearing on the issues, and that leaving it in would cause prejudice (p. 15, quoting Winklevoss Capital Fund, LLC v. Shrem). The court never ruled on the motion: the case was dismissed with prejudice after a reported settlement on July 23, 2025. The allegations about Heid therefore remain unproven, and the argument that they were improper also remains undecided. What ECF 19 documents is that Heid’s lawyers objected, in writing and then in a formal motion, to putting professionally damaging personal claims into a public court record in a case about a marketing campaign and a stock-option deadline.

09The amended complaint

Escalation also has a mechanism, and it does not belong only to the defense. Under Rule 15(a), a party may amend its pleading once as a matter of course, generally within 21 days after serving it or after the other side’s responsive pleading or motion, and after that with the opposing party’s written consent or the court’s leave, and the rule says “the court should freely give leave when justice so requires.” Leave is not automatic: courts can refuse an amendment that is futile, unduly delayed or brought in bad faith, and once a scheduling order sets a deadline, later amendments require good cause. But the default in federal court is permission, not refusal.

An amendment can change a case’s shape. A narrow dispute over a name or a piece of intellectual property can be amended to add claims arising from the same relationship: breach of contract, unpaid wages or compensation, retaliation, and, where the facts and any required administrative steps support them, discrimination claims. It can add claims based on what a defendant did after the suit was filed, including public statements or other conduct. Heid, before the settlement, could in principle have sought to do so. So can any party in the Factor case, plaintiff or defendant, with every new claim subject to the same Rule 11 duties described above.

It can also change who is in the case. Rule 20 permits joining additional defendants when the claims against them arise from the same transaction or series of occurrences and share a common question of law or fact. In corporate disputes that can mean individual executives or directors, but only on facts showing their own participation; a title alone is not a claim. And the reach of discovery is wider than the list of parties. Rule 26(b)(1) allows discovery of any nonprivileged matter relevant to any party’s claim or defense and proportional to the needs of the case, and Rule 45 subpoenas can compel non-parties to sit for depositions, produce documents or testify at trial. Depending on the claims, that can include board members, current and former executives, business partners and, where they have relevant knowledge, friends or family members of the people involved.

That is the strategic risk in pleading personal matters a case does not need. Allegations about someone’s character invite a response about character, and an expanded complaint can turn a contained contract dispute into years of discovery into the conduct of the people who chose to escalate it. Lawyers in New York are also bound by the Rules of Professional Conduct, including Rule 4.4(a), which bars a lawyer representing a client from using “means that have no substantial purpose other than to embarrass or harm a third person.” No court or disciplinary body made any finding against counsel in the Heid case, and this site does not suggest one would have. But the lesson applies to every case, including this site’s owner’s: a pleading that reaches beyond its claims can serve a client poorly, and the lawyers who sign it answer for it under their own names.

10Defense, leverage, or both

Companies are entitled to defend their contracts, and counterclaims are routine in federal court. Nothing in this record proves bad faith by SecurityScorecard or its lawyers. But counterclaims change a case’s economics regardless of intent. A plaintiff who sued over his name now faced a claim for damages and fees. Personal allegations placed in a public pleading can follow someone in search results long after a case closes, and, as explained above, statements in court filings are generally shielded from defamation claims by the litigation privilege. Those are the mechanics of leverage. Whether they were the point here is something the record cannot answer.

11How it ended

On July 23, 2025, the court entered an order dismissing the case with prejudice following a reported settlement (ECF 27). The claims cannot be refiled. No court decided whether Heid’s likeness was misused, whether his options were wrongly withdrawn, whether he breached any agreement, or whether any background allegation was true. Settlement terms, if any, have not been disclosed, and this article does not infer them.

12Documents and methodology

This analysis rests on four filings in Heid v. SecurityScorecard, Inc., No. 1:25-cv-01734-JSR (S.D.N.Y.), available through the public docket and PACER: Heid’s Complaint (Document 1, February 28, 2025); the defendants’ 15-page Answer and SecurityScorecard, Inc.’s Counterclaims (Document 14, April 16, 2025); Heid’s memorandum of law in support of his motion to strike or dismiss the amended counterclaims (Document 19, June 11, 2025), which also describes the First Amended Answer (Document 15, May 16, 2025), not reviewed directly; and the order of dismissal (Document 27, July 23, 2025). Complaint material is Heid’s allegation; Answer material is the company’s. Both filings were read in full for this article. Quotations are reproduced as they appear in the filings, which are themselves allegations. Characterizations such as “scorched earth” and the questions about leverage are this site’s commentary. The leadership chart uses public sources listed in its notes and is not evidence of why any executive left.

ECF 19 · Plaintiff Alexander Heid’s Memorandum of Law in Support of His Motion to Strike or Dismiss Defendants’ Counterclaims and Certain Affirmative Defenses (S.D.N.Y., filed June 11, 2025, 26 pages)Open · Download

Key pages: equity dispute, pp. 8–11; April 22 warning and amended answer, pp. 12–13; motion to strike the background allegations, pp. 15–16. Page numbers are the court’s “Page N of 26” stamps.

Related investigations